Beachcombers in San Diego got the fright of their lives when they spotted a grotesque-looking sea creature washed ashore on Torrey Pines State Beach last Tuesday. The discovery made waves online after images and videos of the eerie flotsam surfaced.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9c053/9c0537c6ffb2b31e9da1ad0c5cda44ed22f0f224" alt=""
Jay Beiler, who stumbled upon the creature, initially mistook it for a jellyfish, but upon closer inspection, he realized it was a fish. By then, a crowd had gathered to marvel at his find, which he described as “the stuff of nightmares.” His photos showed the creature with rows of undulating teeth and a fleshy tassel on its head, as though it were designed by Tim Burton.
The Scripps Institution of Oceanography later identified the creature as a Pacific Footballfish, one of the larger species of anglerfish that can reach a maximum length of 2 feet. This oceanic predator is notable for its fleshy, bioluminescent head protrusion that it uses to lure small prey, hence its “angler” namesake, according to the California Academy of Sciences.